Young Will is standing on a stage, about to start singing when he looks up and sees the auditorium is completely empty. A single tear rolls down his face. He begins singing the song “Nobody Forever” Young Will’s piece of the song is hopeful, revealing his big plans to become famous, but after a time-skip to older him, he’s accepting that he’ll be a nobody forever.
The Great Nimo is a big-time celebrity magician, walking out of his tour bus in slow-mo, doing various magic tricks for students crowding around him, about to perform a show at the school. He’s a very cocky, confident guy, and he sings “I’m F*cking Magical,” through this whole introduction, glossing over deep feelings of regret about his past, pretending pain doesn’t matter when you’ve got magic!
Will is pacing back and forth in the hallway, practicing asking out Maya. A bell rings, and a whole group of students begin crowding into the auditorium to see Nimo’s show. Will tries to make his way through the crowd and get Maya’s attention, but ends up getting trampled by everyone. Eventually, he’s all alone on the floor, and sings “Nobody Forever (Reprise),” accepting that people don’t care about him.
Will is stopped in a spotlight as he enters. Nimo is about to perform his final trick, and calls Will to the stage. Nimo writes Will’s name in a magic book, and tells everyone it can see into one’s reality. Will tries to say no, until it begins to project traumatizing scenes of Will’s most embarrassing, heartbreaking experiences, including him cutting. This shocks the room, and everyone including Maya is speechless.
Smash cut to Will in bed, crying hysterically, when his mom walks in the room. She quietly sits next to him, and after more silence, says she is really sorry, softly singing “Someone to Love You.” Will continues to cry, but thinks about what Hope says, until he eventually falls asleep. Even if he won’t admit it, he’s happy she was there for him.
Nimo magically appears next to Will in the bathroom, like a genie. He half-asses an apology in the most insincere way possible. He hilariously starts to play the victim, blaming Will for leaving all this guilt on his conscience. Nimo eventually offers Will the book, explaining that anything he writes in it comes true. He sings “Rewrite” and transfers its ownership to him. but cautions Will that NO ONE else may use it.
Will is standing in the hallway, when a few people bully him about the magic act, making fun of his cuts. Will takes the book and writes his first wish, “I matter to people.” To Will’s surprise, the bullies apologize to him. Other people around the school begin telling him how strongly they relate to his experiences, and apologize that this happened to him. All the well wishes take Will by surprise as the whole school joins in an anthem, “We Are Here for You.”
Will is alone in a practice room writing a new song. Suddenly, Maya enters the room, apologizing to him about the magic act. He tells her that it really means a lot to him. She asks what he’s doing, and he says he’s just struggling to write a song. She says she writes songs, too, and suggests that the two of them should put on a concert! Suddenly, Will hesitates, recalling the last time he threw a concert. Maya plays an uplifting song, “Don’t Run Away,” as they start putting up fliers for the concert. They have an “almost kiss.”
Will is sitting at the beach, reflecting on how his life is starting to improve, when Nimo appears. Nimo asks what the hell Will’s been doing with the book, considering he isn’t off signing autographs or getting laid. Nimo looks through it and laughs hysterically at Will’s singular pathetic wish, so the two of them sing “Why Stop There?” in which Nimo convinces Will to use the book to become disgustingly famous.
Will begins singing a calm, but upbeat song, “Worst Things/Best Things,” showing how he’s surprised the worst things that have ever happened to him became the best thing that’s ever happened to him. Now, all of a sudden, people care about him. This is intended as an emotional solo, where he sings directly to the audience.
Hope is crying. Will enters. He asks what’s wrong, and Hope says Will’s dad was yelling at her for suggesting marriage counseling. She apologizes for how hard they’ve made Will’s life, when he says he’s actually been doing better. Hope is so proud of him! Will tells her about the book, then exits. Hope sings “I Deserve a Little Magic,” and writes in the book behind Will’s back, “I have a happy marriage.”
Will and Maya finish planning the concert, when Will notices a scar on Maya’s forehead. She tells him it was a minor injury from when she and her brother used to go on adventures. She says that She’s been alone for so long after he ran away, and everything getting better so quickly feels too good to be true. Will shares the feeling as the two of them sing “Fiction,” going on a montage of dates, and ending with a kiss cus people go crazy for that shit I guess.
Nimo's magic begins going wrong in a magic show, embarrassing him in front of thousands of people, and then, he realizes his dick has disappeared. Afraid of what's happening, he finally decides to confront the mysterious cave where he found the book in the first place. The mischievous voice of the cave sings, "Fake," telling Nimo that writing "fake." in the book is the only way to undo the mistake, at the cost of also undoing every good thing the book has brought anyone.
Will is walking home from Maya’s, when Nimo runs up to him in a panic. He says that the book’s rules were violated, and reality itself is beginning to vanish. The only way to stop it is to write “fake,” which will disenchant the book. Will asks what happens then, and Nimo replies that every wish will be reversed. Confident that no one else used the book, Will thinks Nimo is lying, and sings “Bravo.”
Will runs away, and all of a sudden, Nimo begins to disappear. All he can do is watch helplessly and panic as he disappears. He chokes on his tears, trying to deny that he’s seconds away from death. He begins to cry as he sings “Everything is Fine!” By the time the song ends, he has completely disappeared, cutting him off before the last word of the song, “fine.”
When Will returns home, he finds his parents sharing a romantic candlelit dinner. He mentions that they always fight, so something must be wrong. Hope then reveals that she may or may not have used the book, but then she points out how happy it has made everyone, and thanks Will. At this moment, Will realizes Nimo was telling the truth, and in shock, slowly walks to his room to check the book.
Will picks up the book, about to write, “fake,” but instead, writes his name again to watch his life project from the book like it did in the magic act. As he watches his past experiences up close, all the pain floods back to him, and he sings a sad, emotional song, “Vanishing,” pretty much admitting that he’d rather die than go back to how shitty and awful his life was before.
Will is driving up to the school for the night of the concert, and he sees a metric f*ckton of people crowded around the building, including news reporters and helicopters. When he gets out of the car, everyone is singing “We Are Here for You (Reprise),” and suddenly, he sees Maya standing across the crowd. Everyone parts the sea for him and he walks toward her. They enter the building.
Maya is standing on stage, welcoming everyone, and about to sing her first song. Will is watching from backstage, staring at the music for a song he wrote, “Real Life.” Maya starts to sing “Don’t Run Away (Reprise)” - VERY IMPORTANT PIECE! This indirectly convinces Will not to let everyone vanish, but to instead disenchant the book. Will crumples up his song. Maya finishes playing, and introduces Will.
After a long moment of dead silence, Will finally gets on stage in front of everyone, shaking. After some more silence, he tells them that reality is disappearing. He explains to everyone that the truth is none of them actually care about him. He just used a magic book to make them. In real life, he’s a nobody. In tears, he begins singing “Lose it All,” in which he finally writes “fake,” and once again finds himself standing alone on a dark stage.
Unaware that the enchantment was broken, Hope is minding her own business, when her husband bursts through the front door, all angry. She doesn’t understand what’s going on, and the two get into an aggressive, loud fight, where shit gets thrown. Eventually, Hope has enough, and kicks Will’s dad out once and for all, finally singing “I Swear.”
Will is sitting at the beach once again, all alone, watching the book drown. A stranger walks up to him, and says thank you. It is Nimo, but his actual name is Nick Moore, brother of Maya Moore. He and his sister used to go exploring all the time. One day, they followed a treasure map to the book. Maya was nearly killed. The guilt led Nimo to run away and never look back, using the book to change everything about himself. After all this time, he’s learned that running away wasn’t the answer.
